Star Wars has always been one of the most beloved franchises in cinema history, but the debate around its recent direction just doesn’t seem to end. After the mixed reception of The Last Jedi and the heavy criticism aimed at The Rise of Skywalker, many fans have started wondering if Disney should hit the reset button on the saga altogether.

What’s surprising, though, is that fans aren’t just talking about redoing the Sequel Trilogy. Some are even suggesting that Disney should remake the Prequels—and shockingly, even the Original Trilogy. For lifelong fans, that idea feels almost untouchable, yet the conversation is gaining momentum online.

Why Fans Want a Reboot

On the r/StarWars subreddit, a simple question sparked heated debate: “Can you imagine a future where Disney reboots Star Wars?” While many assumed it was just about the Sequels, plenty of fans took it further, arguing that the entire saga could be retold from the ground up.

~ Also Read

Mazey Village on Steam: The Cozy Puzzle Adventure That Lets You Befriend Adorable Animals

Some commenters compared Star Wars to the Marvel Cinematic Universe, suggesting Disney could learn from Marvel’s long-term storytelling approach. They argue that with a dedicated creative leader ensuring continuity, Star Wars could reboot with a more focused plan, building from beginning to end without unnecessary jumps in storytelling.

Others want to see more depth given to underexplored characters. Leia Organa, for example, is a figure many believe never got her full story arc as both a leader and Force user. Fans believe a reboot could give her and other characters more spotlight and stronger development.

The Bold Suggestions

One group of fans believes Disney should go beyond simply remaking the old movies. Instead, they suggest creating a completely fresh storyline—set in a new era with new heroes, villains, and conflicts. This would free the franchise from the baggage of the Skywalker Saga while still keeping the Star Wars spirit alive.

But skeptics quickly point out a huge problem: Disney’s track record. Some fans argue that the company focuses too much on turning out annual content rather than building a thoughtful, cohesive story. A true reboot would require patience, risk-taking, and a long-term creative vision that Disney hasn’t always shown with Star Wars.

~ Also Read

Cyberpunk 2077 Sequel: Will Multiplayer Finally Become a Reality?

The Controversy of Touching the Originals

Rebooting the Sequels might not sound outrageous. Many fans already agree that The Rise of Skywalker left them unsatisfied, and giving those films a second chance could win back some goodwill. But the idea of redoing the Original Trilogy is where things get dangerous.

The classics—A New Hope, The Empire Strikes Back, and Return of the Jedi—are sacred to generations of moviegoers. Recasting Luke Skywalker, Han Solo, or Princess Leia with modern actors would likely trigger outrage across the fandom. Imagine the backlash if Luke were suddenly played by someone like Timothée Chalamet. For many fans, that would feel like erasing a piece of film history.

Is a Reboot Worth the Risk?

While some argue that a reboot could revive Star Wars with stronger stories and modern vision, others believe it risks destroying the legacy of what made the franchise iconic in the first place. The Original Trilogy remains untouchable to many, and even the Prequels—once mocked—have now earned a sense of nostalgic respect among fans.

At best, a reboot of the Sequels could give Disney a chance to rebuild trust with disappointed fans. But attempting to restart the entire saga might do more harm than good. The galaxy far, far away thrives on its history, and rewriting it completely could leave audiences more divided than ever.

For now, Disney seems focused on expanding the universe through spin-offs, Disney+ shows, and new stories set in untouched timelines. Whether or not a full reboot ever happens, the debate proves one thing—Star Wars fans care deeply about the future of the franchise, and every creative decision will always spark passionate reactions.