Red Dead Redemption 3 Lead Character Leaves Gamers Torn
With the unforgettable journeys of John Marston and Arthur Morgan behind us, and Grand Theft Auto VI on the horizon, speculation about Red Dead Redemption 3 is heating up. One of the biggest debates centers around a single question: who will step into the role of the next protagonist? After two of the most iconic leads in gaming history, Rockstar Games faces a tough challenge in choosing a successor.
Fans of the series believe Rockstar has already left subtle clues in Red Dead Redemption 2 about what direction the story could take. The path forward may depend on whether Rockstar opts for another prequel or decides to move the timeline forward with a true sequel to the first game.
If Red Dead Redemption 3 Becomes a Prequel
Should Rockstar choose to go back in time once again, characters like Hosea Matthews or even Dutch van der Linde are frequently suggested. Exploring their younger years could offer new perspectives on the Van der Linde gang and its rise to power.
Others argue, however, that Rockstar might introduce a brand-new lead character, similar to what they did with Arthur Morgan. A fresh face could allow for an entirely new story, free from the expectations that come with established figures.
If the Story Continues After Red Dead Redemption
On the other hand, if Rockstar develops a true sequel, a few clear candidates emerge. Many fans believe Sadie Adler would be a natural fit, given her compelling arc as a gunslinger trying to carve out her place in a violent world. Another strong option is Charles Smith, whose background as one of the few Native Americans navigating the dangers of the West feels tailor-made for a powerful, meaningful narrative.
Both Sadie and Charles were left with open-ended storylines that almost feel like setups for future exploration.
The Fan-Favorite Choice: Jack Marston
Among the community, the most discussed option is none other than Jack Marston, son of John and Abigail. His journey from an innocent boy to a man burdened by vengeance leaves a lot of room for growth. Some players believe his story could focus on finding peace and breaking free from the cycle of violence that defined his family’s past.
“I’d like to see Jack find redemption and move on, maybe even end the story as a writer instead of an outlaw,” one fan suggested in an online discussion.
Others picture him in the early 20th century, perhaps during the Prohibition era or even conscripted into World War I, forced to reconcile his hatred for the U.S. government with the reality of war.
A Bold Idea: Multiple Protagonists
Another intriguing theory is that Rockstar could feature more than one lead. Much like Grand Theft Auto V allowed players to switch between multiple characters, Red Dead Redemption 3 could follow Jack, Sadie, and Charles at different points in time. Since only about 15 years separate the end of RDR2 and John Marston’s death in the first game, it’s plausible their stories could overlap.
Looking Ahead
Of course, at this stage, Rockstar Games hasn’t announced anything official. For now, the studio is likely focused on finalizing GTA VI and its online features. Still, the demand for another Red Dead entry is massive, and fans remain hopeful the wait won’t be as long as it has been for the next Grand Theft Auto.
Whether the next outlaw tale belongs to Jack, Sadie, Charles, or someone entirely new, one thing is certain: Red Dead Redemption 3 will have enormous shoes to fill. After Arthur and John, expectations couldn’t be higher.
Hi, I’m Waqas, the author behind EisoTech. Gaming has always been more than just a hobby for me—it’s a passion that connects people and cultures. Through this platform, I share updates, reviews, and insights about the latest trending games so fellow gamers can stay ahead of what’s new and exciting.
